Phillip Securities Group
Please note that the Day Light Saving of Europe and US will be effective on April 1st and March 11th respectively. The trading hours for those relevant contracts will be 1 hour earlier. Any questions, please contact us at 22776677.For details, please visit our foreign futures website or contact us at 22776677.Moreover,the spread of USD/JPY is low as one pip.Please click here for details
Research Report: Stock codeG
  02-05-2019 (�|)    China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Satisfactory growth on student enrollment, but still with policy risks
  30-04-2019 (�G)    China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Satisfactory growth on student enrollment, but still with policy risks
  29-04-2019 (�@)    China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Satisfactory growth on student enrollment, but still with policy risks
  14-12-2018 (��)    China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Fair annual results along with larger policy risks
  13-12-2018 (�|)    China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Fair annual results along with larger policy risks
[1 / @3]
China Maple Leaf Education Limited(1317)
02-05-19
  Share this articleG    
Recommendation on   02-05-19 
Recommendation Reduce
Price on Recommendation Date $ 4.240
Suggested purchase price N/A
Target Price $ 3.780
Weekly Special - 601021.CH SPRING Airlines
Written by: Terry Li( Research Analyst )
Tel:
+852 2277 6527

Email:
terryli@phillip.com.hk

China Maple Leaf Education Limited (1317.HK) - Satisfactory growth on student enrollment, but still with policy risks

Investment Summary

China Maple Leaf Education Systems Limited is a leading international school operator, from preschool to grade 12 education (K-12) in China. Although the valuation lifted recently thanks to the rumor of a looser regulation on ¡§Education Promotion Law¡¨, we believe that even if there are any difference in regulations compared with "Draft for deliberation ", the main content will not change much. Therefore, the business risk on compulsory education and kindergarten are still very high. As a result, we downgrade the rating from ¡§Neutral¡¨ to ¡§Reduce¡¨, with a TP of HK$ 3.78, 10.8% potential downside. (Closing price at 25 April 2019)

Business Update

The group announced that as of March 31, 2019, the number of students enrollment was 41,380, an increase of 38.0% over the same period last year and an increase of 13.2% from October 15, 2018. During the period, the Group acquired a 66% equity interest in a primary and secondary school in Luzhou, Sichuan Province on December 10, 2018 at a consideration of RMB 185 million. The consideration will be paid in cash and allotment and issuance of new shares of the Group to the Vendor. Subsequently, on December 27, 2018, the Group increased its shareholding of 9% by RMB 25.2 million, which lifted the total equity interest held by the company to 75%. The school enrollment was about 3,200 and the school can accommodate a total of 3,500 students. The annual tuition fee ranges from RMB 20,000 to RMB 25,000. In 2018, 4 out of 5 highest scoring students of Luzhou municipal middle school exam were from this school, implying the quality of school education.

Policy risks

It is reported that ¡§Education Promotion Law¡¨ will be legislated this year. We believe that even if there are any difference in regulations compared with "Draft for deliberation ", the main content will not change much. For example, there will a non-profit and For-profit classification for private schools, non-profit schools will receive the same benefits as public schools, compulsory education does not allow to choose for-profit and private education should be a supplement to public education.

From a practical point of view, if the non-profit and for-profit classification needs to be implemented literally, the first thing the government needs to resolve is the problem that the compulsory education school will be profitable in the name of non-profit. If the compulsory education school still allows to make use of the legal loopholes to distribute dividends to shareholders, and at the same time continue to enjoy the benefits as a non-profit school, higher education schools may adopt the same method to its maintain non-profit status and will have lower incentives to shift to for-profit status, making the classification failed to perform.

In addition, if there are still legal loopholes in the industry that allow schools to make profits in the name of non-profits, it will certainly lead to a unfair competition to higher education schools that have been shifted into for-profits, and they may therefore protest.

Therefore, we see that the probability of the policy to be implemented literally is very high, business risks on the compulsory education and kindergarten of the Group shall be very large, and even need to spin off to the corporate structure.

Valuation

Although the valuation lifted recently thanks to the rumor of a looser regulation on ¡§Education Promotion Law¡¨, we believe that even if there are any difference in regulations compared with "Draft for deliberation ", the main content will not change much. Therefore, the business risk on compulsory education and kindergarten are still very high. It is very likely that the business will not be able to pay dividends to shareholders in the future. However, since it is generally believed that there will be five-year grace period, we assume that compulsory education and kindergarten business spin off five year later. We maintain 4x P/E ratio for the business to reflect its value before divestiture.

Owing to the satisfactory growth in school enrollment, we increased the CAGR on adjusted net profit in 2019-21F to 19%, with 0.9x PEG, reflecting the increase in the effective tax rate and the payment of land transfer fees after the high school segment turning into for-profit.

We derive a TP of HK$3.78, 11.8% higher than the previous TP to reflect the satisfactory growth in school enrollment. However, as the stock price goes up recently, we downgraded the rating from ¡§Neutral¡¨ to ¡§Reduce¡¨, with a potential downside of 10.8%. (CNY/HKD = 0.8656)

.

Risk

1. VIE structure prohibited in China

2. The grace period of policies is shorter than expected

3. New acquired schools were not able to add value

Financials

.

Click Here for PDF format...

Back to Top


Information contained herein is based on data obtained from recognized statistical services, issuer reports or communications, or other sources believed to be reliable. However, we do not verify such information. We do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness, nor do we take responsibility for any loss occasioned by reliance placed upon the contents hereof. Any statements nonfactual in nature constitute only current opinions, which are subject to change. Phillip Securities (HK) Ltd (or one of its affiliates) or their officers, directors, analysts, or employees may have positions in securities or commodities referred to herein, and may, as principal or agent, buy and sell such securities or commodities. An employee, analyst, officer, or a director of Phillip Securities (HK) Ltd, or its affiliates, may serve as a director for companies mentioned in this report. Neither the information nor opinion expressed in this report shall constitute a solicitation to buy or sell any securities. There may be instances when fundamental, technical, and quantitative opinions may not be in concert. This firm (or one of its affiliates) may from time to time perform investment banking or other services for, or solicit investment banking or other business from, any company mentioned in this report.
There are risks inherent in international investments, which may make such investments unsuitable for certain clients. These include, for example, economic, political, currency exchange rate fluctuations, and limited availability of information on international securities. We recommend that you obtain the advice of your Financial Advisor regarding this or other investment in order to conform to your financial resources and risk preference

Copyright © 2011 Phillip Securities Group. All Rights Reserved [ Risk Disclosures Statement ] [ Terms and Conditions ] [ Personal Data Policy ]